Comparison

What to look for in an AI receptionist: a practical checklist

A practical checklist for judging any AI receptionist: how calls are answered, routed, handed to your EMR, and escalated, plus honest tradeoffs to weigh.

By MedReception AI, physician-built by Paul Toomey, MDPublished

How it pays back

What happens when the phone rings

Katie answers right away and can take unlimited simultaneous calls, Annie covers after-hours around the clock, and Victoria turns voicemail into a summary your staff can act on. A voicemail-first or phone-tree setup may be enough for a very quiet line. For busy front desks, heavy call volume and hold times cause hang-ups, and practices miss about 30 to 50 percent of their calls, so it is worth asking any vendor exactly what a caller hears when staff are tied up.

Routing that follows your rules

A good setup routes by provider, by urgency and by triage rules your practice defines, using templates built for your specialty. At MedReception, the AI routes and escalates and clinicians decide. It does not make clinical decisions. Ask any vendor to walk through an urgent call, a routine call and a call for a specific provider so you can see where each one lands.

Getting the call into your workflow

Each call produces a structured summary that staff can paste into the EMR, and Sallie handles scheduling requests. MedReception connects to a named list of EHRs, and for an EHR outside that list Katie still answers every call, handles intake and sends booking requests that your staff enter. Ask every vendor, including us, which EHRs it connects to today and what happens if yours is not one of them.

Privacy and compliance you can verify

MedReception is HIPAA compliant, verified by Compliancy Group, and signs a BAA. For Canadian practices it follows PIPEDA and PHIPA, and for Australian practices the Privacy Act and the APP. Whichever vendor you evaluate, ask who verifies its compliance and get the BAA in writing before any patient call is handled.

Custom setup and the freedom to switch EMRs

MedReception is custom-built per client rather than plug-and-play, and Bailey guides onboarding alongside a real team. Changes to your AI after launch are covered by free lifetime edits and optimization. An AI feature bundled inside an EMR is convenient because it lives in one system, but it stays tied to that EMR. MedReception is EMR-independent, so if you switch EMRs you keep your AI.

Answers right away

Katie handles unlimited simultaneous calls instead of sending callers to hold

Covers after-hours 24/7

Annie answers nights and weekends, and Victoria turns voicemail into a summary

Clinicians decide

The AI routes and escalates; it never approves, denies or changes a prescription

Keep your AI if you switch EMRs

Built around your practice, not tied to one record system

Frequently asked questions

How do I evaluate any AI receptionist?

Ask what a caller hears when several people call at once and when the office is closed. Ask how routing is set up by provider, urgency and triage, and who makes clinical decisions. Then ask which EHRs it connects to, how refill requests are handled, and who edits your setup after launch.

Does MedReception work with my EMR?

MedReception integrates with athenahealth, eClinicalWorks, Elation, Cerbo, Hint, Tebra, ModMed, Practice Fusion, Jane, Office Ally, SimplePractice, TherapyNotes, Accuro, pMD, PS Suite, Nextech, ChARM, Amazing Charts, Azalea Health, Eye Cloud Pro and HealthQuest. If your EHR is not on that list, such as MEDITECH, OSCAR, Valant or WebPT, we do not integrate with it today. Katie still answers every call, handles intake and sends booking requests that your staff enter. Want MedReception integrated with your EHR? We build custom EHR integrations; book a demo and we will scope yours.

How is an AI receptionist different from an answering service?

An answering service uses human operators to take messages. MedReception's AI answers using the routing rules and specialty template built for your practice, then hands staff a structured summary. Victoria also turns voicemail into a summary. The tradeoff is that you set up rules in advance, which is why we build them with you and keep editing them at no charge.

What does the AI do with prescription refill requests?

It never approves, denies or changes a prescription. Where your EHR supports it, including eClinicalWorks, it prepares a pending refill for the prescriber to sign. Otherwise it sends the request to the provider as a message.

What should I do before choosing a vendor, and what does MedReception cost?

Book a demo and ask each vendor to show your own call scenarios. MedReception plans include a monthly block of minutes, then a per-minute rate, with free setup, free texting and month to month billing cancelled with 30 days' written notice. For a limited time, a two month pilot is offered with a demo: one flat monthly fee with unlimited AI minutes for two months from go live. There is no free plan, and launch takes about a week from signup, so see /pricing for current plans.

Related reading

Bring this to your practice

See how MedReception AI handles after-hours calls, scheduling, intake, and patient communication for medical practices like yours.

Want the numbers first? See plans and pricing